New approaches are needed to deal with sluggish growth, low interest rates, and an absence of inflation. Secular stagnation even truer today, larry summers says. Rather, in the words of investment manager james montier of the gmo llc, secular stagnation is a policy choice that we as citizens and policymakers can confidently attack, especially as cyclical. Professor of economics, american university, washington, dc 20016, usa. Summers the nature of macroeconomics has changed dramatically in the last seven years. The supply side of secular stagnation refers to potential real gdp growth, that is, the growth rate of output consistent with the natural rate of unemployment. Economists, such as larry summers have written on secular stagnation arguing the world has entered a period of substantially lower economic growth.
It suggests a change of fundamental dynamics which would play out only in its own time. Six years after the global crisis, the recovery is still anaemic despite years of nearzero interest. Bank of new york, and was a doctoral fellow of the board of governors of the federal. First, the world has been haunted for a very long time, well before the crisis, by a structural aggregate demand deficiency that is likely to persist well into the future and keep growth sluggish. Economic stagnation is a prolonged period of slow economic growth traditionally measured in terms of the gdp growth, usually accompanied by high unemployment. On falling neutral real rates, fiscal policy, and the risk of secular. It needs to be merged with economic stagnation where it belongs. The secular stagnation hypothesis can be summarised in three propositions. Secular stagnation, hysteresis, and the zero lower bound lawrence h. If secular stagnation really exists, the current economic rebound will only be a temporary episode. If this is the case, bonds will continue to surprise positively, while risky assets will become vulnerable. I distinguish four potential explanations for this phenomenon. The experience of first japan and now europe and the usa suggests that hansens concept of secular stagnation is highly relevant. Secular stagnation in the open economy american economic.
The secular stagnation project will shed light on and explore policy responses to a pressing worldwide issue, which up to this point, has received limited rigorous study. Secular stagnation and the zero lower bound this brings us to the secular stagnation hypothesis put forward by hansen 1939. Now, instead of being concerned with minor adjustments to stabilize about a given trend, concern is focused on avoiding secular stagnation. He points to factors, such as ineffective monetary policy and weak demand for. In this context, the term secular means longterm from latin saeculumcentury or lifetime, and is used in contrast to cyclical or shortterm. Well, we have three sets of theories, and here is a graph showing trend growth, potential output, and actual output that. Pdf critics have long questioned the feasibility and desirability of exponential. Chapter 2 low equilibrium real rates, financial crisis. The economist explains what it means to suffer from. That is because its not being used primarily as an explanation of lower growth, but as an excuse for increased in inequality. Consequently the level and rate of change of private debt could have been macroeconomically significant not merely since 2008, but since as long ago as. Policies, secular stagnation, and outlook in the aftermath of the recent global financial crisis, advanced economies have continued to experience sluggish growth. Six years after the crisis and the recovery is still anaemic despite years of zero interest rates. In general, a marketbased economy affected by secular stagnation is characterised by low or absent economic growth, low inflation and low interest rates.
The concept of secular stagnation originally formulated by the eminent depressionera economist alvin hansen, has experienced a revival since my. The world economic forum is an independent international organization committed to improving the state of the world by engaging business, political, academic and other leaders of society to shape global, regional and industry agendas. It is too early to tell whether secular stagnation is really secular. The standard economic models are not equipped to address this unique interest rate environment and the situation presents multiple lines of inquiry that deserve exploration. Pdf the postgrowth challenge secular stagnation, inequality.
On secular stagnation in the industrialized world brookings. Pdf when secular stagnation meets pikettys capitalism. The supply side of secular stagnation refers to potential real gdp growth, the growth rate of output consistent with steady nonaccelerating inflation. This debate has forwarded both demand and supplyside arguments regarding the pros and cons of secular stagnation. Secular stagnation hansens thesis features secular. The debate about the new secular stagnation hypothesis has gained momentum and many facets have recently been added.
Incorporated as a notforprofit foundation in 1971, and headquartered in geneva, switzerland, the forum is tied to no political, partisan or national. Secular stagnation a prolonged period in which satisfactory growth can only be achieved by unsustainable financial conditions may be the defining macroeconomic challenge of our times. But averting it requires making the right policy choices, ending the. The question, of course, is why growth has been so sluggish. Secular stagnation is not inevitable, summers wrote earlier this week. Demand side secular stagnation american economic association.
December 7, 2016 abstract we formalize the idea of secular stagnation and evaluate it quantitatively. And the european economy, like the american economy, had unsustainable finance in the pre 2008 period and has had manifestly unsatisfactory growth in. Secular stagnation is a term coined to describe a prolonged period of lower economic growth. To find the source of the myth that is secular stagnation, economists need only look in the mirror. Secular stagnation can arise if there is a persistent decline in the natural rate of interest, which, if severe. It is said that we are faced by headwinds that inevitably will slow down growth and perhaps condemn us to. Secular stagnation, rational bubbles, and fiscal policy. Nothing more than a phony rationale for more government waste. July 4, 2014 abstract in this paper we propose a simple overlapping generations new keynesian model in which a permanent or very persistent slump is possible. In a new report, beyond secular stagnation, morgan stanley s global investment committee deconstructs the consensus view by examining some of the most frequentlycited drivers of secular stagnation.
Heres why larry summers is wrong about secular stagnation. The basic notion behind secular stagnation is this that the capitalistic economy is basically characterized with instability. What mainstream economists get wrong about secular stagnation. Thats why i took such exception to dsquareds defense of the finance industry as mere bystanders. Is this slow postcrisis growth the result of a policy response that was overly reliant on monetary policy, which ran into the. Pichelmann when secular stagnation meets pikettys capitalism in the 21 st century page 15 poverty is a multidimensional concept which relates not only to the lack of income and wealth but. One of the main driving forces of secular stagnation, according to hansen, was a decline in the population birth rate and an oversupply of savings that was suppressing aggregate. Eprs secular stagnation and the euro area members research service page 5 of 8 this forms the basis of summers new secular stagnation hypothesis. Secular stagnation, internal limits, biophysical limits. Secular stagnation and monetary policy federal reserve bank of. Secular stagnation and macroeconomic policy, mundellfleming lecture, by lawrence h. Secular stagnation, rational bubbles, and fiscal policy coen n. This paper formalizes and quantifies the secular stagnation hypothesis, defined.
Secular stagnation in the form of slow potential output growth over the past halfdecade reflects the slowness of growth in both labor productivity and in aggregate hours of work, and slow growth in the latter is due both to slowing population growth and to a decline in the labor force participation rate lfpr. Countries suffering from the stagnation bug are burdened with too. Larry summers, for one, thinks that its part of a longerterm trend towards what. This idea was termed the secular stagnation hypothesis. Ultimately, while secular stagnation is a powerful metaphor for our current malaise, we dont think its useful for investing. Point of view accepting the reality of secular stagnation. Secular stagnation effects on financial markets seeking. Low equilibrium real rates, financial crisis, and secular stagnation 43 throughout the 1980s. Economic fluctuations and growth, monetary economics conditions of secular stagnation low interest rates, below target inflation, and sluggish output growth now characterize much of the global. Secularstagnation theory originated with alvin hansen, a keynesian economist, in the 1930s.
The harvard economist and former treasury secretary first offered the bleak diagnosis in november 20 at an international monet. Facts, causes and cures edited by coen teulings and richard baldwin centre for economic policy research 77 bastwick street, london ec1v 3pz tel. T his characterization has generated calls for more government spending stimulus. Under some definitions, slow means significantly slower than potential growth as estimated by macroeconomists, even though the growth rate may be nominally higher than in other countries not experiencing. This ebook gathers the views of leading economists including summers, krugman, gordon, blanchard, koo, eichengreen, caballero, glaeser and a dozen others. The reference to secular stagnation and technology is more insidious under the current situation. In economics, secular stagnation is a condition when there is negligible or no economic growth in a marketbased economy. The us economy has experienced a slowdown in its longterm growth and job creation that predates the great recession. How to tackle secular stagnation world economic forum. Servaas storm wrote the below commentary in response to several of the papers presented at inets secular stagnation conference in december 2017. The postgfc environment of subdued interest rates and growth in the u. He has analyzed trade cycles, as well as he has suggested the measures regarding sustained economic growth. It will be interesting to see future research that merges the.
A lazy profession revives a phrase meant to whitewash its own policy failures. This article was created by a disruptive editor trying to push pov. Importantly, we believe our insights come from combining the. Prior to joining nomura, he was an economist with the federal reserve. Secular stagnation institute for new economic thinking. A defining element of secular stagnation theories is that, unlike the many analyses of liquidity trap situations in the tradition of krugman 1998 in which it is assumed, there is no deus ex machina that will return the economy to a situation of positive real interest rates at some future point. The secular stagnation hypothesis, by contrast, is the view that the economy can no longer be trusted to maintain an adequate level of demand. Secular stagnation has attracted a lot of attention since 2009. Larry summers is doubling down on his secularstagnation hypothesis.
1187 1213 482 1340 86 1223 373 337 756 1070 728 982 1068 308 1054 704 151 414 1448 1619 196 343 524 307 1325 1380 391 142 95 49 320 852 211